As I predicted in my posting of March 10, 2007 “When Focus Shifts to Giuliani, Romney Will Surge”, there are indications that Rudy Giuliani’s statements on abortion have begun to affect his status in the polls.
During the recent Republican presidential debate, Giuliani seemed to stumble on the question posed to him regarding the repeal of Roe vs. Wade.
Strategists said Giuliani hurt himself among party conservatives in last Thursday’s debate during a question on whether he would support repealing the 1973 Roe v. Wade abortion rights issue. In the debate, Giuliani said “it would be OK” to repeal the law — but also OK if it were upheld. –Records: Rudy Gave to Abortion Group, May 7, 2007
Today, it was revealed that Rudy Giuliani together with his second wife Donna Hanover, donated to various Planned Parenthood organizations in 1993, 1994, 1998, and 1999. The supporting information shows up in Giuliani’s tax returns. The revelations were released to the press by an un-named rival campaign.
Rudy Giuliani has sought to allay the fears of conservative Republicans by saying that he would appoint “strict constructionist” judges in the model of Samuel Alito. It is thought that these types of judges would reject the liberal attempts to find new rights in the constitution. However, Giuliani’s recent statements seem to be in conflict.
Here is a partial transcript of an April 4th interview of Rudy Giuliani with CNN’s Dana Bash.
BASH: Is that also going to be your position as president?
GIULIANI: Probably. I mean, I have to re-examine all of those issues and exactly what was at stake then, and it is a long time ago. But generally that is my view, abortion is wrong, abortion shouldn’t happen, personally you should counsel people to that extent. When I was mayor, adoptions went up, abortions went down, but ultimately it is a constitutional right, and therefore if it is a constitutional right ultimately, even if you do it on a state-by-state basis, you have to make sure that people are protected.
BASH: So you support taxpayer money or public funding for abortions in some cases?
GIULIANI: If it would deprive someone of a constitutional right, yes, I mean, if that the status of the law, then I would, yes. –Giuliani’s Abortion Folly, April 7, 2007
These statements have alarmed Rudy Giuliani’s would be supporters.
There was an early sign yesterday his once-firm grip on the lead in the race for Republican nomination is weakening, as a new CNN/Opinion Research Poll shows him at his lowest level since August, with just 25 percent support among registered Republicans. John McCain, the Arizona senator, has 23 percent, effectively a tie, given the poll’s margin of error of plus or minus 5 percent. –Records: Rudy Gave to Abortion Group, May 7, 2007
The drop in Giuliani’s numbers is good for Mitt Romney. A new poll shows Mitt taking the lead in New Hampshire. More on that tomorrow.